Trade In Your Engagement Ring or Fine Jewelry

Ready for something new? Your current engagement ring or fine jewelry may have value you can put toward your next piece from Rinner’s Jewelry.

Whether you’re looking for a larger center diamond, a new setting, a different style, or simply something that better reflects where you are today, we’ll evaluate your current piece and provide an offer based on its condition, materials, diamonds, gemstones, brand, and current market value.

Upgrade a Ring You Already Own

We evaluate qualifying engagement rings from many jewelers and online retailers, including pieces originally purchased from Brilliant Earth, Rare Carat, Brilliance, Blue Nile, James Allen, and others.

You are not required to return to the retailer where your ring was originally purchased. If your piece is a good fit for Rinner’s, an approved trade-in value can be applied toward a new purchase.

We also consider select fine jewelry, including diamond earrings, rings, bracelets, necklaces, and estate jewelry.

How the Trade-In Process Works

1. Tell us about your jewelry
Provide information about the piece, including metal, diamond or gemstone details, certification if available, brand, condition, and photos.

2. Receive an evaluation
We review the information and determine whether the piece is something Rinner’s is interested in purchasing or accepting as a trade-in.

3. Upgrade to something new
If you accept our offer, the approved value can be applied toward a qualifying purchase from Rinner’s Jewelry.

What We Look For

We are especially interested in:

  • Diamond engagement rings

  • Lab-grown diamond engagement rings

  • Branded engagement rings

  • GIA- or IGI-certified diamonds

  • Gold and platinum fine jewelry

  • Quality estate and vintage jewelry

  • Select diamond earrings and other fine jewelry

Not every piece will qualify, and trade-in values vary based on condition, current market demand, materials, diamond or gemstone quality, and other factors.

Ready to See What Your Jewelry May Be Worth?

Contact Rinner’s Jewelry with details and clear photos of your piece. We’ll review the information and let you know the next step.

There is no obligation to accept an offer.

Rinner’s Jewelry is an independent jeweler and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Brilliant Earth, Rare Carat, Brilliance, Blue Nile, James Allen, or other brands referenced on this page. Brand names are used only to identify jewelry that customers may own.